suicide prevention

The Papageno Effect: Harnessing Positive Storytelling for Hope and Recovery in Suicide Prevention

Earlier this year,  I attended the European Symposium on Suicide and Suicidal Behavior (ESSSB) in Rome. One of the plenary presentations by Prof Thomas Niederkrotenthaler, of the Medical University of Vienna,  illuminated the powerful impact of the “Papageno Effect” on suicide prevention. 

Unlike the “Werther Effect”, where media portrayals of suicide can lead to imitative behaviors (aka Copycat or Contagion), the “Papageno Effect” focuses on the protective benefits of positive storytelling. Named after a character in Mozart's opera "The Magic Flute," who chooses life over death after being reminded of alternative solutions for coping with his misery, this effect underscores the importance of sharing stories of hope and recovery.

The Power of Positive Storytelling


Research has increasingly demonstrated that stories showcasing personal experiences with suicidal ideation, followed by narratives of overcoming these challenges, can significantly reduce suicidal thoughts among individuals exposed to such content. Niederkrotenthaler's studies have shown that these stories, which portray resilience and coping strategies, not only decrease suicidal ideation but also increase knowledge about suicide prevention and encourage help-seeking behavior​.

The Papageno Effect works by presenting alternative coping mechanisms, providing hope, and emphasizing the possibility of recovery. This approach is particularly effective when the storytellers themselves have lived experiences of suicidal thoughts or attempts and have successfully navigated through these dark periods to emerge stronger. It helps vulnerable individuals see that there is hope and that their situations, while dire, are not insurmountable.

Linking Research to Practice: United Suicide Survivors International


At United Suicide Survivors International, we have integrated the principles of the Papageno Effect into our work, particularly through our storytelling online courses and retreats. These programs are designed to empower suicide attempt survivors and those affected by suicide by teaching them how to share their stories effectively and safely. Our online education courses and storytelling retreats offer a supportive space where participants can craft their narratives of hope and recovery, equipping them with the tools to inspire others and potentially save lives.

One of our key initiatives, the Eye of the Survivor Storytelling Retreat, has shown remarkable results. According to recent feedback, 72% of participants found the retreat to be extremely impactful, with many noting increased confidence in sharing their stories in both private and public settings​. This aligns with findings from Niederkrotenthaler’s research, which highlights the positive effects of sharing personal recovery stories in public forums.

Real-Life Impact of Storytelling: Recent Findings


Our recent retreats and workshops, like the one covered in KSHB's "Eye of the Survivor" (Kansas City, MO) segment (2024), have further reinforced the importance of storytelling in suicide prevention. Participants from the retreat reported feeling empowered and more connected to others who have experienced similar struggles. Such connections foster a sense of community and belonging, crucial elements for recovery and prevention. The video can be viewed here.

Additionally, the Construction Mental Health Storytelling Retreat highlighted in the video titled "Survivor Stories Unleashed" (2024) showed that storytelling could break down barriers and biases and build support networks in even the most rugged professional environments. The retreat provided a platform for sharing experiences, which is vital for creating understanding and fostering mental health awareness. 

The Art and Science of Storytelling in Suicide Preventiondelves into how narratives can influence emotions, thoughts, and behaviors. Storytelling helps create emotional connections and can change perspectives on life and death, encouraging individuals to seek help and support. 

Join Us and Become Part of the Change


The evidence is clear: positive storytelling can save lives. If you are interested in learning how to share your own story of hope and recovery or want to support others in doing so, consider enrolling in our online courses or attending one of our storytelling retreats

These programs provide invaluable skills and a supportive community, empowering you to contribute to a global movement of hope and recovery.

Enroll today and become part of the change by telling your story through a hero’s journey framework: Online Education | Workshops and Retreats https://www.unitesurvivors.com/workshopsretreats 

Videos on Storytelling and Suicide Prevention
KSHB
(2024). "Eye of the Survivor' supports suicide prevention through storytelling". This video segment covers the impact of the Eye of the Survivor Storytelling Retreat on suicide prevention. Available at: YouTube.

Survivor Stories Unleashed (2024). Empowering Journeys at Construction Mental Health Storytelling Retreat. This video highlights the storytelling retreat for mental health in the construction industry. Available at: YouTube.

The Art and Science of Storytelling in Suicide Prevention. This video explores the influence of storytelling on suicide prevention strategies. Available at: YouTube.

References

Niederkrotenthaler, T. et al. (2019). Suicide and the Media: From Werther to Papageno Effects – A Selective Literature Review. Suicidologi, 2(2019). This study provides an overview of how positive media portrayals (Papageno Effect) can reduce suicidal ideation and promote hope and recovery.

Spencer-Thomas (2024). Eye of the Survivor Storytelling Retreat Impact Report. Unpublished data from the August 2024 storytelling retreat, showing participant feedback on the impact of the program on their confidence and willingness to share their stories. Findings suggest a significant impact on participants' confidence and likelihood to share their experiences.

Kirchner, S., & Niederkrotenthaler, T. (2019). Experiences of suicide survivors of sharing their stories about suicidality and overcoming a crisis in media and public talks: a qualitative study. BMC Public Health.2024 Jan 10;24(1):142. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-17661-4. This study focuses on the impact of media on suicide prevention among vulnerable groups.

Niederkrotenthaler, T., Till, B., & Arendt, F. (2019). Effect of educative suicide prevention news articles featuring experts with vs. without personal experience of suicidal ideation: A randomized controlled trial of the Papageno effect. J Clin Psychiatry. This study examines the impact of storytelling on reducing suicidal ideation.

11 Tips to Get Ready for National Suicide Prevention Week/World Suicide Prevention Day

11 Tips to Get Ready for National Suicide Prevention Week/World Suicide Prevention Day

This year, for World Suicide Prevention Day, the theme is “Creating Hope through Action.” For too long we’ve been stuck in “awareness raising” — a necessary but not sufficient condition for change.

It’s time to take action. Here are 10 tips for an impactful National Suicide Prevention Week (September 5-11)/World Suicide Prevention Day (September 10th) - action steps you can take with you to impact your community all year long.

Soul Exhaustion: Going Beyond the Brain in Our Understanding of Suicide Intensity and the Overcoming of It

Soul Exhaustion: Going Beyond the Brain in Our Understanding of Suicide Intensity and the Overcoming of It

There is an element of humanity that is struggling with and ultimately often excluded from conversations about mental health in general and suicide more specifically. That element is spirituality, which may or may not be directly related to religion. Spirituality is difficult to measure and cannot be prescribed and yet for the span of modern human beings it has been a staple in understanding grief, surviving trauma and counteracting the hopelessness that we know fuels despair and suicidal intensity. 

“You Matter to Me”: 4 Reasons Why Peer Support Saves Lives

“You Matter to Me”: 4 Reasons Why Peer Support Saves Lives

The person most likely to save your life from suicide is someone you already know. Sometimes it may be a family member or a supervisor. Often its a peer.

7 Untold Stories of Suicide Prevention and Suicide Grief Support

7 Untold Stories of Suicide Prevention and Suicide Grief Support

…I don’t really have the chops to be a researcher or the patience to be a clinician, but I often find myself in new territories, listening to people share their insights about living through unimaginable suffering. Then I look to connect partners much smarter than I who can make a difference in alleviating that despair. So, as I am listening, I think to myself, “there are the stories I wish we would talk about more.” 

My Night on Stage at the Grammys: Standing Up for Suicide Loss and Attempt Survivors

My Night on Stage at the Grammys: Standing Up for Suicide Loss and Attempt Survivors

That moment when you are standing shoulder-to-shoulder with fellow suicide loss and attempt survivors on the Grammy’s stage at Madison Square Garden during the grand finale while nominees Logic, Khalid and Alessia Cara sing 1-800-273-8255…and you think – maybe, just maybe, our time has come…

Why Impact Entrepreneurship Matters to Me and the Cause of Mental Health Promotion and Suicide Prevention

Why Impact Entrepreneurship Matters to Me and the Cause of Mental Health Promotion and Suicide Prevention

“Applying business skills to resolving social ills…part saint, part politician, part business person,” said Robert Redford about social entrepreneurs.

What is Impact Entrepreneurship?

Social entrepreneurs, or “Impact Entrepreneurs,” as I like to call them, bring together the best of the nonprofit heart and the for-profit efficiency. They are the ideal blend of the best of both worlds and the future of how business and social change gets done.

5 Ways to Tap into Hope as a Defiant Superpower against Despair

5 Ways to Tap into Hope as a Defiant Superpower against Despair

I have often said, “Hope is the antidote to suicide.”

I realize that the word “hope” – like “love” and “support” and “leadership” – is often experienced as cliché, having lost its power and meaning from overuse. I would like to reclaim it and use it like Wonder Woman’s shield (goodness I love that movie) to defiantly deflect pessimism, bitterness and negativity coming at us from all angles.

As advocates for suicide prevention and mental health promotion, we must be warriors of hope.  Now is the perfect time to explore how we can learn to build hope as a practice – like pieces of protective armor that protect us as we forge our way onward to the frontiers of what is possible....

From Vegas to Columbine to Workplace Violence: Understanding the Complexities Surrounding Murder-Suicide

From Vegas to Columbine to Workplace Violence: Understanding the Complexities Surrounding Murder-Suicide

In the aftermath of the October 1st, 2017 massacre in Las Vegas, which left 58 people dead and more than 500 others injured, we have more questions than answers, and we are wondering -- even more than usual –- what would drive someone to do that?

15 Top Apps for Resilience, Mental Health Promotion & Suicide Prevention

15 Top Apps for Resilience, Mental Health Promotion & Suicide Prevention

When we consider a comprehensive strategy to suicide prevention and mental health promotion, it’s helpful to segment approaches into “upstream” (preventing problems before they emerge through self-help), “midstream” (catching emerging problems early and linking people to least restrictive support), and “downstream” (helping people with more serious mental health challenges and suicidal thoughts) tactics.

Thus, for this article, I have organized some of the most popular, best researched and most innovative apps into these three categories.

Reasons You Should Be Concerned about Suicide in the Animal Welfare/Medicine Industry

Reasons You Should Be Concerned about Suicide in the Animal Welfare/Medicine Industry

...One example of a “caring for others” profession is veterinary medicine and animal welfare. Animal rescue professionals and veterinarians fit Thomas Joiner’s model of why people die by suicide: Constant exposure to death and feelings of hopelessness lead to an acquired ability for lethal self-injury, and they have access to lethal means in the form of drugs.

People are often drawn to the demanding professions because of their love of animals, but they soon discover that a large part of the job involves ending the lives of beloved pets and otherwise health animals. In fact, vets come face-to-face with death at five times the rate of physicians. Both veterinarians and animal rescue professionals are witness to the agonizing situation of pet owners choosing to have their companions euthanized because treatment is too expensive or too difficult or because breeding was uncontrolled and the family has become overwhelmed....